8 Movies and Shows Similar to A Kidnapping in Amish Country (2024)

Description: Shares with 'A Kidnapping in Amish Country' the theme of outsiders interacting with the Amish community, though in this case it's a more positive story about family bonds across cultural divides.

Fact: Based on the novel 'The Redemption of Sarah Cain' by Beverly Lewis. Filmed in Virginia's Shenandoah Valley. Features a soundtrack with authentic Amish hymns.

Description: Similar to 'A Kidnapping in Amish Country' due to its focus on Amish culture and the dramatic tension within the community. Both explore themes of family conflict and the clash between traditional values and modern influences.

Fact: Based on a novel by Beverly Lewis, a well-known author of Amish fiction. The film was shot on location in Canada, standing in for Pennsylvania Amish country. It was originally produced as a Hallmark Channel movie.

Description: Shares the true crime and mystery elements with 'A Kidnapping in Amish Country', focusing on dark events within an Amish community. Both delve into the hidden aspects of Amish life that contrast with their peaceful reputation.

Fact: The film claims to be based on true events in Ohio's Amish country. It blends documentary-style storytelling with dramatic reenactments. The movie explores the little-known phenomenon of Amish folk magic practices.

Description: Like 'A Kidnapping in Amish Country', this reality series examines the tension between Amish traditions and the modern world, though from the perspective of young adults leaving the community rather than a criminal event.

Fact: The show was controversial for allegedly faking some elements of its 'reality'. It spawned several spin-off series. Featured former Amish participants who had never used modern technology before filming.

Description: Similar dark tone to 'A Kidnapping in Amish Country', exploring frightening events in Amish communities, though with a supernatural rather than criminal focus.

Fact: Part of the 'A Haunting' documentary-style horror series. Features first-person accounts of paranormal experiences. Uses dramatic reenactments with Amish consultants for authenticity.

Description: Like 'A Kidnapping in Amish Country', this documentary examines the harsh consequences of breaking Amish rules, though focusing on voluntary leaving rather than criminal abduction.

Fact: Produced by PBS's American Experience series. Features interviews with actual ex-Amish individuals. Explores the psychological impact of shunning on families.

Description: Shares with 'A Kidnapping in Amish Country' an unflinching look at dark aspects of Amish life, particularly focusing on Amish teenagers' rumspringa period which often involves criminal behavior.

Fact: The documentary inspired a fictionalized series on Showtime. Director Lucy Walker spent years gaining the Amish subjects' trust. Reveals widespread drug use during rumspringa.

Description: While more uplifting than 'A Kidnapping in Amish Country', both deal with traumatic events in Amish communities and how they respond to violence, based on the real 2006 Nickel Mines school shooting.

Fact: Based on the book 'Amish Grace: How Forgiveness Transcended Tragedy'. Features authentic Amish actors in supporting roles. The real Amish community consulted on the film but didn't participate directly.