10 Shows & Movies Similar to The Irrational (2023)

Description: 'Monk' and 'The Irrational' both center on brilliant but socially awkward detectives who use their unique perspectives to solve crimes. While 'Monk' is more comedic, both shows explore the protagonists' personal struggles and how their quirks aid their investigative skills. The procedural format and focus on detail-oriented problem-solving are also similar.

Fact: Tony Shalhoub won three Emmys for his portrayal of Adrian Monk. The character was inspired by Sherlock Holmes and other iconic detectives. The series finale was one of the most-watched episodes in USA Network history.

Description: 'Criminal Minds' and 'The Irrational' both delve into the psychology of criminals and victims, though 'Criminal Minds' is more focused on profiling serial killers. Both shows use behavioral science to solve crimes and feature ensemble casts with strong, charismatic leads. The dark, suspenseful tone is also a common thread.

Fact: The show's technical advisor is a former FBI profiler. Matthew Gray Gubler, who plays Dr. Spencer Reid, is also a talented artist and director. The series has one of the largest episode counts for a crime drama, with over 300 episodes.

Description: 'Bones' and 'The Irrational' both combine crime-solving with scientific expertise, though 'Bones' focuses on forensic anthropology. Both shows feature strong, intelligent leads who use their specialized knowledge to crack cases. The blend of procedural elements with character-driven storytelling is a key similarity.

Fact: The show is loosely based on the life of forensic anthropologist Kathy Reichs, who is also a producer. Emily Deschanel, who plays Temperance Brennan, is a vegetarian in real life, unlike her character. The series ran for 12 seasons, making it one of the longest-running crime dramas.

Description: Like 'The Irrational,' 'Psych' features a protagonist with exceptional observational skills, though it leans more into comedy. Both shows highlight the power of perception and intuition in solving crimes, but 'Psych' does so with a lighter, more humorous tone. The dynamic between the lead and his best friend also mirrors the collaborative spirit seen in 'The Irrational.'

Fact: The show's creators originally pitched it as a drama but were encouraged to make it a comedy. James Roday Rodriguez, who plays Shawn Spencer, ad-libbed many of his lines. The series has a cult following and spawned three TV movies after its conclusion.

Description: 'The Mentalist' shares with 'The Irrational' a protagonist who uses psychological insight and behavioral analysis to solve crimes. Both shows mix procedural crime-solving with personal vendettas, as the main characters are driven by past traumas. The charismatic lead and the blend of humor and drama are also common elements.

Fact: Simon Baker, who plays Patrick Jane, was nominated for a Golden Globe for his performance. The character of Patrick Jane was inspired by real-life mentalists and psychics, though the show emphasizes his use of observation and psychology rather than supernatural abilities. The series finale was watched by over 10 million viewers.

Description: 'Castle' and 'The Irrational' both feature charismatic, unconventional protagonists who bring a fresh perspective to crime-solving. While 'Castle' is more lighthearted, both shows mix procedural elements with character-driven narratives and romantic tension. The witty dialogue and dynamic partnerships are also similar.

Fact: Nathan Fillion, who plays Richard Castle, is a huge fan of 'Firefly,' and references to the show appear in 'Castle.' The character of Castle was inspired by real-life mystery writers like Stephen King. The show was canceled after eight seasons but remains popular in syndication.

Description: Similar to 'The Irrational' (2023), 'Lie to Me' focuses on the science of human behavior and deception. Both shows feature protagonists who use their expertise in psychology to solve crimes, blending procedural elements with deep character studies. The analytical approach to crime-solving and the emphasis on non-verbal cues make them intellectually engaging.

Fact: The show is loosely based on the work of real-life psychologist Paul Ekman, a pioneer in the study of emotions and facial expressions. Tim Roth, who plays Dr. Cal Lightman, initially turned down the role but changed his mind after meeting with the producers. The series was canceled after three seasons despite a dedicated fan base.

Description: 'White Collar' and 'The Irrational' both feature protagonists with unique skill sets who work with law enforcement to solve crimes. The charm and intelligence of the leads, along with the focus on high-stakes, intellectually stimulating cases, are key similarities. Both shows also explore themes of redemption and trust.

Fact: Matt Bomer, who plays Neal Caffrey, was almost cast as Superman in a canceled film. The show's creator, Jeff Eastin, is a fan of classic con artist movies like 'The Sting.' The series finale was intentionally left open-ended to allow for potential spin-offs.

Description: 'Sherlock' and 'The Irrational' both feature protagonists with unparalleled analytical skills who solve crimes through keen observation and psychological insight. The modern setting and high production values of 'Sherlock' align with the sleek, contemporary feel of 'The Irrational.' Both shows also explore the personal demons of their leads.

Fact: Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman, who play Sherlock and Watson, both starred in 'The Hobbit' films. Each episode is 90 minutes long, resembling a mini-movie. The show's creators, Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss, are both huge Sherlock Holmes fans.

Description: 'Elementary' and 'The Irrational' both modernize classic detective tropes with a psychological twist. Sherlock Holmes in 'Elementary' uses deductive reasoning and behavioral analysis, much like the protagonist in 'The Irrational.' Both shows also delve into the personal growth of their leads and their relationships with their partners.

Fact: This was the first American television series to feature a female Dr. Watson, played by Lucy Liu. Jonny Lee Miller and Benedict Cumberbatch, who played Sherlock in 'Elementary' and 'Sherlock' respectively, are close friends in real life. The show was filmed in New York, unlike most Sherlock adaptations which are set in London.