If you're a fan of 'Dexter: New Blood' (2021), you're likely craving more shows or movies that blend psychological thrills, dark humor, and morally complex protagonists. This article curates 10 gripping titles that share the same eerie atmosphere, intricate storytelling, and suspenseful twists as Dexter's return to the screen. Whether you're drawn to antiheroes, crime dramas, or chilling mysteries, this list will keep you on the edge of your seat.

Prodigal Son (2019)
Description: Shares with 'Dexter: New Blood' the theme of a protagonist connected to serial murder (Malcolm Bright's father is a serial killer). Both explore the psychological impact of this connection and feature crime-solving elements. The dark family dynamics and psychological thriller aspects are similar.
Fact: Michael Sheen plays the serial killer father with charismatic menace. The show was cancelled after two seasons despite a dedicated fanbase. Tom Payne prepared for his role by studying criminal psychology.


The Following (2013)
Description: Like 'Dexter: New Blood', this show features a charismatic serial killer (Joe Carroll) and explores the psychology of both killers and those who pursue them. Both shows have a cat-and-mouse structure and delve into the nature of obsession. The dark tone and violent content are comparable.
Fact: Kevin Bacon starred in his first regular TV role for this series. The show was created by Kevin Williamson, known for 'Scream' and 'The Vampire Diaries'. The series finale had a controversial ending that divided fans.


Bates Motel (2013)
Description: Similar to 'Dexter: New Blood' in its exploration of a character's descent into darkness (Norman Bates' transformation into a killer). Both shows examine the nature vs. nurture debate and feature complex mother-son relationships. The psychological horror elements are also comparable.
Fact: The series serves as a contemporary prequel to 'Psycho'. Vera Farmiga received critical acclaim for her role as Norma Bates. The show was filmed in British Columbia, standing in for the fictional town of White Pine Bay.


Hannibal (2013)
Description: Similar to 'Dexter: New Blood' in its exploration of a complex protagonist with a dark secret (Hannibal Lecter as a cannibalistic psychiatrist). Both shows delve into the psychology of their main characters, blending crime procedural elements with psychological horror. The visual aesthetics are also similarly stylish and atmospheric.
Fact: The series was developed by Bryan Fuller, known for his visually distinctive shows like 'Pushing Daisies'. Despite critical acclaim, the show was cancelled after three seasons due to low ratings. Mads Mikkelsen's portrayal of Hannibal Lecter was praised for its sophistication and chilling calmness.


The Fall (2013)
Description: Like 'Dexter: New Blood', this show features a cat-and-mouse game between a serial killer and a law enforcement officer. Both explore the duality of human nature and the psychological depth of their characters. The moody, atmospheric tone is also comparable.
Fact: Gillian Anderson's performance as DSI Stella Gibson was widely acclaimed. The show was one of the first BBC dramas to be set and filmed in Northern Ireland. Jamie Dornan's portrayal of Paul Spector was his breakout role before 'Fifty Shades of Grey'.


True Detective (2014)
Description: Shares with 'Dexter: New Blood' a dark, atmospheric tone and exploration of criminal psychology. Both shows feature complex protagonists with troubled pasts and use nonlinear storytelling. The philosophical undertones and focus on character development are also similar.
Fact: Each season features a new cast and storyline. Matthew McConaughey's performance in Season 1 revitalized his career. The show's title sequence and music have become iconic.


Barry (2018)
Description: While more comedic, 'Barry' shares with 'Dexter: New Blood' the premise of a killer trying to leave his past behind and start anew. Both explore the psychological toll of violence and the difficulty of changing one's nature. The dark humor and moral ambiguity are also comparable.
Fact: Bill Hader co-created the series and directs many episodes. The show blends genres, combining crime drama with dark comedy. Henry Winkler won an Emmy for his role as acting teacher Gene Cousineau.


Killing Eve (2018)
Description: Similar to 'Dexter: New Blood' in its focus on a complex relationship between a killer and someone trying to catch them. Both shows feature strong female leads and explore themes of obsession and identity. The stylish production and dark humor are also points of similarity.
Fact: The show was originally developed by Phoebe Waller-Bridge. Jodie Comer learned multiple languages and accents for her role as Villanelle. The cat-and-mouse dynamic was inspired by real-life female serial killers.


You (2018)
Description: Shares with 'Dexter: New Blood' the theme of a protagonist who justifies his violent actions. Both shows use internal monologues to reveal the protagonist's thoughts, creating a similar narrative style. The exploration of obsession and the blurred lines between love and violence are common themes.
Fact: The show is based on Caroline Kepnes' novel of the same name. Penn Badgley initially auditioned for a different role before being cast as Joe Goldberg. The show's second season was filmed in Los Angeles but set in New York due to tax incentives.


The Sinner (2017)
Description: Like 'Dexter: New Blood', this show explores the psychology behind violent acts, often revealing unexpected motivations. Both feature protagonists with hidden depths and use mystery elements to unravel character backstories. The dark, psychological tone is comparable.
Fact: The first season was based on Petra Hammesfahr's novel. Jessica Biel served as executive producer for the first season. Each season features a new case with Detective Harry Ambrose as the connecting thread.
