10 Gripping Shows & Movies Like ‘Sherri Papini: Caught in the Lie (2025)’

Description: This series shares with 'Sherri Papini: Caught in the Lie' a focus on a high-profile case where the truth is murky and the protagonist's actions are heavily scrutinized. Both explore the media's role in shaping public perception of the accused.

Fact: Based on the Michelle Carter case, which involved a controversial 'texting suicide' trial. Elle Fanning plays the lead role. The case raised legal questions about accountability in the digital age.

Description: Both 'The Thing About Pam' and 'Sherri Papini: Caught in the Lie' center around women who orchestrate elaborate deceptions. The stories examine how these women managed to deceive those around them and the eventual unraveling of their lies.

Fact: Starring Renée Zellweger in a transformative role. Based on a Dateline NBC podcast. The real Pam Hupp is currently serving a life sentence.

Description: Like 'Sherri Papini: Caught in the Lie', 'Dirty John' delves into the dangers of deceit and the impact of a charismatic liar on those around them. Both stories highlight how easily people can be manipulated and the long-term consequences of such relationships.

Fact: Based on the popular podcast of the same name. The real-life John Meehan's crimes spanned multiple states. Connie Britton and Eric Bana starred in the series.

Description: Like Sherri Papini's story, 'The Imposter' deals with an unbelievable case of deception that fooled many people. Both stories explore why people believe improbable stories and how liars can manipulate emotions and circumstances.

Fact: The imposter, Frédéric Bourdin, assumed the identity of a missing Texas boy. Combines documentary footage with dramatic reenactments. The real Nicholas Barclay's family has disputed the film's portrayal.

Description: Similar to the Papini case, 'The Jinx' follows a real-life individual whose bizarre behavior and possible crimes captivate the public. Both stories involve unexpected twists and turns that challenge viewers' perceptions of guilt and innocence.

Fact: Robert Durst was arrested the day before the finale aired. Features a famous hot mic moment where Durst appears to confess. Directed by Andrew Jarecki, who also made 'Capturing the Friedmans'.

Description: Similar to 'Sherri Papini: Caught in the Lie', 'The Act' explores the theme of deception and manipulation, particularly within a family setting. Both stories involve individuals fabricating or exaggerating their circumstances for personal gain or attention. The psychological depth and true crime elements make them compelling watches.

Fact: Based on the real-life story of Gypsy Rose Blanchard and her mother Dee Dee Blanchard. The series won a Golden Globe for Patricia Arquette's performance. The case inspired multiple documentaries and a podcast.

Description: Similar to the Papini documentary, 'The Staircase' provides an in-depth look at a controversial case where the truth remains elusive. Both explore how personal narratives can conflict with forensic evidence.

Fact: Originally a 8-episode French documentary. The case involved an owl theory as possible explanation. Colin Firth later starred in a dramatized version.

Description: Both this documentary and the Papini case explore how internet communities can help solve crimes. They show how digital footprints can both aid deception and help uncover the truth.

Fact: Begins with investigation of animal cruelty videos. Features amateur internet sleuths who helped track the killer. The killer, Luka Magnotta, was eventually arrested in Germany.

Description: Like Papini's story, this documentary shows how someone can create an elaborate false identity to manipulate others. Both cases involve victims who initially believed the deceiver's stories.

Fact: The swindler, Simon Leviev, conned women out of millions. The real Leviev later tried to capitalize on his notoriety. Inspired warnings about online dating safety.

Description: Both 'Making a Murderer' and the Papini case involve controversial criminal cases where the truth is hotly debated. They showcase how the justice system and media can influence public opinion about guilt or innocence.

Fact: Filmed over 10 years. Sparked widespread debate about Steven Avery's guilt. Led to real-world legal developments in the case.