If you loved the gripping mystery and chilling atmosphere of 'In Cold Water: The Shelter Bay Mystery (2024),' you're in for a treat! This article explores 10 similar movies and shows that will keep you on the edge of your seat with their suspenseful plots, small-town secrets, and unexpected twists. Whether you're a fan of crime dramas or psychological thrillers, these recommendations are sure to satisfy your craving for more.

Mare of Easttown (2021)
Description: A gritty crime drama centered on a small-town detective solving a murder while grappling with personal turmoil. The show's realistic portrayal of community dynamics and the protagonist's emotional struggles resonates with themes of resilience and hidden pain.
Fact: Kate Winslet's performance earned her an Emmy, and the series was praised for its authentic depiction of working-class Pennsylvania life.


Top of the Lake (2013)
Description: A mystery drama set in a remote New Zealand town, where a detective investigates the disappearance of a pregnant girl. The haunting landscape and exploration of gender dynamics and trauma create a deeply atmospheric and emotionally charged narrative.
Fact: Co-created by Jane Campion, the series was filmed in Queenstown and Glenorchy, showcasing the stunning yet eerie beauty of the region.


Broadchurch (2013)
Description: A gripping crime drama set in a small coastal town, focusing on the investigation of a young boy's murder and the ripple effects on the tight-knit community. The atmospheric setting and deep character exploration mirror the tone of mystery and emotional depth.
Fact: The show was filmed in the actual town of Broadchurch, Dorset, lending authenticity to its coastal setting. It won multiple BAFTA awards, including Best Drama Series.


The Fall (2013)
Description: A cat-and-mouse thriller following a detective hunting a serial killer in Belfast. The series excels in building suspense and psychological tension, with a strong emphasis on the killer's psyche and the detective's relentless pursuit.
Fact: Gillian Anderson's portrayal of DSI Stella Gibson was lauded for its intensity and depth, revitalizing her career.


True Detective (2014)
Description: A neo-noir crime anthology series with a focus on dark, philosophical storytelling and intricate character studies. The brooding atmosphere and layered narratives explore the duality of human nature and the impact of crime on individuals and communities.
Fact: The first season's single-director approach by Cary Fukunaga was highly praised for its cinematic quality and cohesive vision.


The Night Of (2016)
Description: A crime drama following a young man accused of murder and the legal and personal fallout of his case. The series meticulously examines the criminal justice system and the protagonist's transformation, blending procedural elements with deep character study.
Fact: Originally developed as a BBC series, it was adapted for HBO and starred Riz Ahmed in a breakout role.


Sharp Objects (2018)
Description: A psychological thriller centered around a journalist returning to her hometown to investigate a series of murders, uncovering dark family secrets. The slow-burning tension and exploration of trauma align with the themes of hidden truths and personal demons.
Fact: Based on Gillian Flynn's debut novel, the series features a haunting soundtrack and was praised for its atmospheric cinematography.


Big Little Lies (2017)
Description: A drama-mystery intertwining the lives of five women in a wealthy coastal community, culminating in a murder investigation. The show's blend of dark humor, suspense, and exploration of domestic secrets creates a compelling narrative.
Fact: Initially planned as a miniseries, its success led to a second season, with Meryl Streep joining the cast.


The Undoing (2020)
Description: A psychological thriller revolving around a wealthy family unraveling after a violent death and the ensuing investigation. The series blends mystery with domestic drama, exploring themes of trust, deception, and privilege.
Fact: Based on Jean Hanff Korelitz's novel 'You Should Have Known,' the show became one of HBO's most-watched limited series.


The Sinner (2017)
Description: An anthology series delving into the psychological motives behind seemingly inexplicable crimes. Each season unravels a mystery rooted in the protagonist's past, emphasizing the complexity of human behavior and hidden motives.
Fact: The first season was adapted from Petra Hammesfahr's novel and starred Jessica Biel in a critically acclaimed role.
