If you enjoyed the eerie found-footage horror of 'Frogman' (2024) and are craving more chilling tales of cryptids and supernatural mysteries, you're in the right place. This article explores 10 similar movies and shows that deliver the same spine-tingling suspense, eerie atmospheres, and unsettling encounters with the unknown. Whether you're a fan of cryptid lore or just love a good scare, these picks will keep you on the edge of your seat.
The Legend of Boggy Creek (1972)
Description: A docudrama-style film blending folklore and horror, focusing on a cryptid creature in rural America, creating an eerie, grounded atmosphere.
Fact: The film was shot on a shoestring budget and became a surprise hit, inspiring a wave of similar regional horror films.
Watch Now 
The Last Broadcast (1998)
Description: A mockumentary-style horror film that predates 'The Blair Witch Project', exploring the aftermath of a mysterious disappearance during a paranormal investigation.
Fact: The film was made for just $900 and was one of the first to use the 'found footage' format in horror.
Watch Now 
The Blair Witch Project (1999)
Description: A pioneering found-footage horror film that uses psychological terror and minimal visuals to create an unsettling, immersive experience in a forest setting.
Fact: The film's marketing campaign famously blurred the line between fiction and reality, leading many to believe it was actual footage.
Watch Now 
The Phoenix Tapes '97 (2016)
Description: A found-footage horror film about a group of filmmakers investigating a government conspiracy tied to alien encounters, blending sci-fi and horror elements.
Fact: The film was shot in a single location over a short period, giving it a raw, unpolished aesthetic.
Watch Now 
The Poughkeepsie Tapes (2007)
Description: A mockumentary-style horror film presenting a series of disturbing videotapes left by a serial killer, using found footage to create a deeply unsettling atmosphere.
Fact: The film was shelved for years due to its extreme content before finally getting a limited release.
Watch Now 
The Bay (2012)
Description: A found-footage ecological horror film that combines documentary-style storytelling with a terrifying outbreak scenario, creating a sense of realism and dread.
Fact: The film uses multiple 'found' video sources, including news footage and personal recordings, to build its narrative.
Watch Now 
Exists (2014)
Description: A found-footage horror film about a group of friends encountering a terrifying creature in the woods, blending survival horror with cryptid mythology.
Fact: The creature effects were created by the same team behind 'The Blair Witch Project', using practical effects for realism.
Watch Now 
Willow Creek (2013)
Description: A found-footage horror film centered around a Bigfoot legend, using suspense and minimal visuals to build tension in a wilderness setting.
Fact: The film features a single 20-minute long take inside a tent, heightening the sense of dread and realism.
Watch Now 
Savageland (2015)
Description: A faux-documentary horror film that uses photographs and interviews to tell the story of a mysterious massacre, blending realism with supernatural horror.
Fact: The film's chilling photographs were created by a professional photographer, adding to its authentic feel.
Watch Now 
Butterfly Kisses (2018)
Description: A meta-horror film that layers found footage with documentary-style storytelling, exploring an urban legend and the blurred lines between truth and fiction.
Fact: The film won the Best Found Footage Feature award at the 2018 Shriekfest Film Festival.
Watch Now 
