If you were captivated by the chilling true-crime drama 'Killer in Plain Sight (2018),' you're likely craving more gripping stories that delve into the dark side of human nature. This article curates 10 movies and shows that share the same suspenseful, psychological thrills, exploring themes of deception, hidden motives, and the terrifying reality that evil can lurk where we least expect it. Whether you're a true-crime enthusiast or simply love a good mystery, these recommendations will keep you on the edge of your seat.

Dirty John (2018)
Description: This series shares with 'Killer in Plain Sight' the theme of dangerous individuals infiltrating ordinary lives. Both explore how charming exteriors can hide violent tendencies, and how victims often don't recognize the danger until it's too late. The focus on psychological manipulation and the true crime basis make them similar.
Fact: Based on the popular Los Angeles Times podcast and article series. Connie Britton and Eric Bana star as the central couple. The real John Meehan died shortly after his crimes were exposed.


The Night Of (2016)
Description: While fictional, 'The Night Of' shares with 'Killer in Plain Sight' an exploration of how ordinary lives can become entangled with violent crime. Both examine the criminal justice system's handling of murder cases and the psychological toll on those involved. The gritty realism and moral ambiguity in both stories create similar unsettling atmospheres.
Fact: Originally developed by Steven Zaillian and the late James Gandolfini. Inspired by the British series 'Criminal Justice'. Riz Ahmed's performance earned him an Emmy Award for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Limited Series.


The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst (2015)
Description: Similar to 'Killer in Plain Sight', 'The Jinx' explores the chilling reality of a murderer living undetected among society. Both delve into the psychological complexity of the killer and the investigative process that eventually uncovers their crimes. The documentary style and real-life footage in 'The Jinx' mirror the authentic and unsettling tone of 'Killer in Plain Sight'.
Fact: The series features a shocking moment where Robert Durst seemingly confesses to his crimes while still wearing a live microphone. Durst was arrested the day before the final episode aired, adding a dramatic real-life twist to the documentary. Director Andrew Jarecki initially explored Durst's story through the fictional film 'All Good Things' before making this documentary.


I'll Be Gone in the Dark (2020)
Description: This series, like 'Killer in Plain Sight', focuses on the hunt for a serial criminal who evaded capture for decades. Both highlight the impact of the crimes on victims and the relentless pursuit of justice by investigators and amateur sleuths. The atmospheric storytelling and emphasis on the criminal's ability to blend into everyday life are key similarities.
Fact: Based on Michelle McNamara's book about her personal investigation into the Golden State Killer. The Golden State Killer was arrested just two months after the book's publication. The series includes never-before-seen footage from McNamara's personal archives.


The Act (2019)
Description: Like 'Killer in Plain Sight', 'The Act' reveals how shocking crimes can occur within seemingly normal families. Both stories involve deception and manipulation hidden behind ordinary facades. The psychological depth given to both perpetrators and victims creates similar disturbing narratives about domestic crimes.
Fact: Based on the true story of Gypsy Rose Blanchard and the murder of her mother Dee Dee. Patricia Arquette won an Emmy for her portrayal of Dee Dee Blanchard. The real Gypsy Rose Blanchard was released from prison in December


The Staircase (2004)
Description: Both 'The Staircase' and 'Killer in Plain Sight' delve into mysterious death cases where the truth remains elusive. They share a focus on the legal process and the ways media can influence public perception of guilt. The ambiguous nature of the crimes creates similar tension and debate.
Fact: Originally released as a French documentary series. Follows the case of Michael Peterson, accused of killing his wife Kathleen. The documentary crew had unprecedented access to the defense team.


Making a Murderer (2015)
Description: Like 'Killer in Plain Sight', this documentary series examines a complex murder case with controversial elements. Both raise questions about the criminal justice system and the possibility of wrongful convictions. The detailed, multi-episode investigation into a single case creates similar immersive storytelling.
Fact: Filmed over 10 years by filmmakers Laura Ricciardi and Moira Demos. Sparked widespread debate about Steven Avery's guilt or innocence. Led to real-world legal developments in Avery's case.


The Keepers (2017)
Description: Like 'Killer in Plain Sight', 'The Keepers' investigates a long-unsolved murder with potential institutional cover-ups. Both explore how power structures can protect criminals and silence victims. The documentary's examination of community trauma and persistent investigative efforts creates similar emotional impact.
Fact: Investigates the 1969 murder of nun Catherine Cesnik. Explores allegations of sexual abuse at a Catholic high school. Features former students who continue to seek justice decades later.


The Confession Tapes (2017)
Description: Similar to 'Killer in Plain Sight', this series examines cases where the truth about crimes may have been obscured. Both explore how confessions can be problematic evidence and raise questions about the reliability of the justice system. The focus on controversial cases creates similar thought-provoking narratives.
Fact: Each episode examines a different case of disputed confessions. Highlights potential issues with police interrogation techniques. Features interviews with legal experts and those involved in the cases.


Evil Genius (2018)
Description: This series, like 'Killer in Plain Sight', examines a bizarre and complex crime that shocked a community. Both explore how ordinary people can become involved in extraordinary criminal plots. The focus on unraveling a puzzling case through investigative journalism creates similar narrative tension.
Fact: Focuses on the 'pizza bomber' heist in Erie, Pennsylvania. Features the infamous 'collar bomb' case. Explores the involvement of Marjorie Diehl-Armstrong, a woman with a history of mental illness.
