If you loved the eerie small-town mystery and supernatural twists of 'Residents of Arcadia' (2021), you're in for a treat. This article explores 10 similar movies and shows that capture the same unsettling atmosphere, hidden secrets, and gripping storytelling. Whether you're craving more paranormal thrills or small-town conspiracies, these picks will keep you hooked.

The Twilight Zone (1959)
Description: Classic anthology series that explores bizarre, supernatural, and often unsettling stories with moral or philosophical undertones.
Fact: Rod Serling wrote over 90 of the original series' 156 episodes. The iconic opening narration has been parodied and referenced countless times in pop culture.


Twin Peaks (1990)
Description: A surreal and mysterious small-town setting with supernatural elements and a focus on uncovering dark secrets beneath the surface.
Fact: The show's iconic red room scenes were inspired by a dream David Lynch had. The character of Laura Palmer was originally intended to remain a mystery, but network pressure led to her killer being revealed in the second season.


The X-Files (1993)
Description: Combines supernatural mysteries with government conspiracies, focusing on two agents investigating unexplained phenomena.
Fact: The show's iconic theme song was composed in just one day. The phrase 'The truth is out there' became a cultural catchphrase.


Lost (2004)
Description: A group of strangers stranded on a mysterious island must uncover its secrets while dealing with personal demons and supernatural occurrences.
Fact: The show's creators initially pitched it as 'Survivor meets Cast Away.' The numbers 4, 8, 15, 16, 23, and 42 became a recurring motif throughout the series.


Fringe (2008)
Description: Mixes science fiction with eerie, unexplained events, often involving parallel universes and bizarre scientific experiments.
Fact: The show's alternate universe was depicted with a slight amber tint to differentiate it from the primary timeline. Many episodes contain hidden glyphs that spell out words related to the plot.


Black Mirror (2011)
Description: Anthology series that delves into the dark side of technology and human nature, often with unsettling and thought-provoking narratives.
Fact: The title refers to the dark reflection seen in a turned-off screen. Each episode is a standalone story, allowing for diverse themes and settings.


Wayward Pines (2015)
Description: A small town with dark secrets and a sense of unease, where residents are trapped and must uncover the truth behind their confinement.
Fact: Based on a book series by Blake Crouch. The show was initially marketed as a limited series but was later renewed for a second season.


The Leftovers (2014)
Description: Explores themes of grief, loss, and existential dread in the aftermath of a mysterious event, blending supernatural elements with deep emotional storytelling.
Fact: The show's opening theme changes slightly each season to reflect the evolving tone. The writers intentionally left many questions unanswered to focus on the characters' emotional journeys.


The Haunting of Hill House (2018)
Description: A family's traumatic past and supernatural experiences in a haunted house are explored through nonlinear storytelling and psychological horror.
Fact: The show features hidden ghosts in the background of many scenes, adding to the eerie atmosphere. The iconic 'bent-neck lady' was inspired by a real sleep paralysis experience.


The Outsider (2020)
Description: A crime investigation takes a supernatural turn as a detective uncovers eerie and inexplicable events surrounding a murder case.
Fact: Based on Stephen King's novel of the same name. The show blends crime drama with horror elements, creating a tense and unsettling atmosphere.
